Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues.
Hire Writer The novel starts off with young British schoolboys, who have suffered a plane crash with no adult left alive. The boys scatter around the island and are brought together by the call of the conch.
By comparison, the movie starts of with American schoolboys who crash in the water and unite while they pull their life raft onto the island. As well, the appearance and characteristics of the characters are dissimilar to how Golding describes them in the novel.
Piggy is described as fat and asthmatic, while Jack is a fiery, freckled, unattractive, red head. However, in the movie, Ralph is fits the stereotype of an All-American, curly headed, skinny boy. Piggy, though still large in the movie, is not asthmatic in the movie. Jack, in the movie, is a bleach-blonde, able-bodied, and attractive character.
Overall, the movie fails to capture tiny details from the novel such as the nationality of the boys, which, though is seemingly minor, changes the impact of the story on audiences.
Secondly, the movie fails to capture the important themes and conflicts as successfully as the book. The theme of adaptability is shown in the novel, especially with Jack, as the boys gradually adapt to life on the island with them constantly going off on their own to explore the jungle.
The movie also shows a sudden, abrupt, adaptation of the boys to the island. In one scene, they are civilized American boys, in the next scene, they are dirty, ragged children climbing trees. As well, the movie, unlike the novel, fails to fully the depict the conflicts that arise in the story.
In the novel, there is a clear case of Man vs. Also in the novel, there is a focus on Man vs. Self where the boys become paranoid and scared. They start to doubt their safety in the island and many of them, especially the younger ones, face internal battles with fear and panic.
Instead of a strong focus on Man vs.
Self, the book fails to give an insight on the emotions and inner battles the boys face in their time on the island. Lastly, the novel succeeds in showing full character development, unlike the movie. One example of this is the character development of Ralph in the novel.
Ralph is susceptible to the same temptations as the other boys but he rises above them and remains civilized. In the movie however, Ralph is automatically portrayed as born leader, instinctually righteous and rational.
The movie depicts Ralph as a civilized chief from the beginning, which is not accurate. The movie makes similar mistakes with the representation of Jack. Jack Merridew is also an example of full character development in the novel. He is introduced as an eager and bossy boy.
Throughout the novel, he develops into a disciplined, militaristic, authoritarian, ruler. He slowly develops to portray calculation, accuracy, and anarchy in the novel.
The movie does not show how Jack, though mean, is just a misguided child in the beginning. The movie is quick to paint Jack is intrinsically evil and sadistic, without any attention to how he develops into the authoritarian leader.
With its attention to detail, emphasis on themes, and focus on character development, the novel proves to be superior to the movie. Though it can be commended that the movie did follow the general plot of the novel, it failed to reach the success that is generally expected from movies based on novels.
How to cite this page Choose cite format:Lord of the Flies comparative essay The novel, “Lord of the Flies” by William Golding was published in It’s the story of a group of boys stranded on an island with no adults.
Since the publications of J. R. R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit and The Silmarillion, a wealth of secondary literature has been published discussing the literary themes and archetypes present in the stories. Tolkien also wrote about the themes of his books in letters to friends, family and fans, and often within the books themselves.
Lord of the Flies: A Comparison of the Novel and the Film Words | 5 Pages. Lord of the Flies: A Comparison of Novel and Film In , at the height of Cold War tensions and in the continually unfolding aftermath of World War II, William Golding produced an allegorical novel of singular potency.
Lord of the Flies is a British drama film, based on William Golding's novel of the same name about 30 schoolboys who are marooned on an island where the behaviour of the majority degenerates into savagery.
It was written and directed by Peter Brook and produced by Lewis M.
alphabetnyc.com film was in production for much of , though the film did not premiere until , and get released in. Lord of the Flies: The Unsuccessful Adaptation - Assignment Example Unfortunately, The Lord of the Flies movie, unlike its novel counterpart, fails to excite the imagination of audiences, due to its failure at capturing the true spirit of the novel.
Art Business Crime essay Economy Education essay Film History Law Literature Marketing. A short William Golding biography describes William Golding's life, times, and work. Also explains the historical and literary context that influenced Lord of the Flies.